Cervical Paravertebral Osteolipoma: Case Report and Literature Review

Article information

Abstract

Introduction

Lipomas are the most frequent soft tissue tumors [1]. They can appear in any location, but are usually found in subcutaneous regions, often in the soft adipose tissue of the neck, back, and extremities [2]. They occur most commonly in adults. On gross examination, they are tan-to-yellow lobulated masses with thin strands of intervening fibrous septae.

Lipomas can include a variety of other mesenchymal elements, leading to neoplasms, such as fibrolipomas, angiolipomas, chondrolipomas, and ossifying lipomas (osteolipomas) [3]. Lipomas that are ossified are most often within or adherent to adjacent bone, known as interosseous or perosteal lipomas, respectively [4].

When a lipoma independent of a bone undergoes ossification, it is referred to as an ossifying lipoma or an osteolipoma. This is a rare variant that can be difficult to diagnose using imaging methods and they can be challenging to differentiate from benign lipomas [5].

Case Report

We report the case of a 66-year-old man with a history of diabetes and hepatic steatosis, who was referred to the Department of Orthopedics for the evaluation and treatment of a tumor in the right paravertebral cervical region.

He had first noted the tumor more than 2 years earlier, and it had grown slowly since then without symptoms until a few months ago, when he experienced pain and dizziness. He had no family history and had not suffered any severe trauma or irradiation of the region.

On physical examination, we found a hard tumoration, adhered to deep planes, well demarcated, large in size, and without other signs. The patient had full neck range of motion. Neurologically, the patient showed no sign of myelopathy or neurological focality, only occasional dizziness with cervical flexion.

Diagnostic imaging, including plain radiograph and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), was obtained before referral. Plain radiographs demonstrated an about 8×3×4 cm calcified, right-sided, paravertebral mass posterior to C2-C6 (Fig. 1). The MRI showed a 10×3 cm mass with a lipid component and calcifications inside within the right paravertebral musculature that could have originated in the right C3 posterior root (Fig. 2).

Fig. 1

(A, B) Plain radiographs indicating the calcified paravertebral mass.

Fig. 2

(A, B) Magnetic resonance imaging showing the lipid component and calcifications of the tumor within the right paravertebral musculature and showing the relationship with the right C3 posterior root (circle).

A computed tomography (CT) scan was ordered for further characterization. The CT showed a well-delineated, encapsulated 73×28×38 mm mass with fat tissue and an important calcifying tissue independent of the vertebrae (Fig. 3). In the CT scan, the calcifications did not appear chondroid or osteoid. To make a diagnosis, we performed CT-guided biopsy that revealed hematic material and small bone spicules with no apparent neoplastic element.

Fig. 3

(A, B) Computed tomography showing the mass with fat tissue and calcifying tissue independent of the vertebrae.

Without knowing clearly the origin of the tumor (lipomatous, neurogenic, or osteocondroid), we decided on surgery, after performing an excisional biopsy due to the seemingly benign characteristics on punch biopsy and absence of any associated toxic syndrome.

Intraoperatively, a mass of 5×10 cm, beginning at the height of C2 and T1 coming up on the right side was observed (Fig. 4). It showed calcifications and seemed to be associated with the right C3 posterior nerve (Fig. 5).

Fig. 4

Intraoperative picture showing the position of the paravertebral mass.

Fig. 5

Intraoperative picture showing the relationship between the C3 posterior root and the paravertebral mass.

The final outcome of the pathology revealed mature adipose tissue proliferation with presence of trabecular bone and hematopoietic bone marrow (Fig. 6). Lamelar bone tissue contained areas of osteoid and plexiform bone tissue, including the presence of a small amount of hyaline cartilage. Thus, this benign lipoma was diagnosed as an osteolipoma. The tumoration included the right C3 posterior branch of the nerve, confirmed by the pathologist, to be normal peripheral nerve tissue. The patient's postoperative course has been uneventful, with no sign of recurrence at 6 months postoperatively.

Fig. 6

Picture showing mature adipose tissue proliferation with presence of trabecular bone and hematopoietic bone marrow (H&E, ×100).

Discussion

Lipomas are benign tumors, composed of mature adipose cells. The lipomatous component is always predominant in these lesions [2]. Ossification of these tumors is extremely rare, and osseous changes independent of bone attachment is the most unique of the variants [6]. When a lipoma undergoes osseous changes (including mature bone tissue differentiation, even with hematopoietic marrow) without bony attachment and fatty tissue predominates, it is referred to as an osteolipoma or ossifying lipoma [1].

An osteolipoma presents as an asymptomatic, slow-growing, round or discoid mass with a soft or doughy consistency. Most cases go undetected for years because of the asymptomatic and indolent nature of this tumor [4]. Lipomas with osseous changes have the same prognosis as plain lipomas. Surgical excision is the recommended treatment [7]. The differential diagnosis includes benign tumors that may contain bone, including teratomas or dermoids. Tumor calcinosis and calcification in a bursa must also be considered [7]. Other conditions, such as ossifying fibromas, myositis ossificans, and osteosarcomas, have to be taken into consideration [5].

The histiogenesis of ossifying lipomas is still unclear. Some investigators have suggested that blood-borne monocytes or osteogenic factors convert fibroblasts into osteoblasts in a metaplastic response. Others have argued that systemic and local factors, such as microtrauma and mechanical stress, cause the changes. It has also been suggest by some authors that lipomas ossifying independent of bone are more likely to be mesenchymomas, in which pluripotent cells differentiate into both adipose and bone separately [4,8]

Lipoma with ossification was described for the first time in 1959 [9]. In a series of 635 lipomas seen over a 5-year period, only six cases with ossification were found [1]. Several sites have been reported: in the soft tissues of the trunk and the extremities [2,10,11,12], the joint space of the knee [13], the neck region [3] (including the retropharyngeal region [14], the parapharyngeal space [4,5,15,16], and the oropharynx [17]) the oral cavity (the most common site) [6,18,19,20,21,22], the skull base [23] and both the intraspinal [24,25,26] and intracranial cavities [27,28,29,30]. There only five cases described in the literature related directly to spine (Table 1); three of them were intraspinal osteolipomas [24,25,26], another was located in the anterior aspect of C1-C2, considered the neck region [4], and the most similar to our case report, was located intramuscularly at the paravertebral cervical spine [31]. Our case report is the first male with spine-related osteolipoma, found in the posterior aspect of the cervical spine, independent from the cervical vertebra, incorporating the C3 posterior branch.

Table 1

Published case report of osteolipomas directly related to spine

Article information Continued