Cerebrospinal Fluid Leakage after Surgeries on the Thoracic Spine: A Review of 362 Cases
Article information
Abstract
Study Design
A retrospective clinical review.
Purpose
To describe the incidence of cerebrospinal fluid leakage (CSFL) after thoracic decompression and examine the CSFL predisposing clinical factors.
Overview of Literature
CSFL is a common complication following thoracic decompression but has not been sufficiently addressed in former studies.
Methods
A cohort of 362 cases of thoracic decompression from February of 2005 to June of 2013 was examined. The case medical records were reviewed and the occurrence of CSFL and the related clinical parameters were noted. The incidence of CSFL for the entire cohort and each surgical approach were described. Besides, the relationship between CSFL and other clinical parameters were assessed, of which odds ratio values of all CSFL-associated parameters were calculated using multivariate logistic regression analysis.
Results
The incidence of CSFL for the entire cohort was 32.3%. Different surgical approaches had different incidences of CSFL, and circumferential decompression had the highest incidence. Though many different clinical parameters were related to the occurrences of CSFL, being older than 52 years, having ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament or having longer operative segments than 3 vertebrae were significant risk factors for CSFL (p<0.05). Besides, surgeries on the mid-thoracic spine had an increased risk of CSFL (p<0.05).
Conclusions
From our analysis, CSFL was a common complication after thoracic decompression with the incidence of up to 32.3%. This study identified the predisposing clinical factors, and spinal surgeons should be aware of these risk factors to reduce its incidence.
Introduction
Surgery on the thoracic spine is a great challenge for spinal surgeons, and frequently complicated by undesirable events, such as cerebrospinal fluid leakage (CSFL). The CSFL incidences for cervical and lumbar spine had been characterized [1234], but those for thoracic spine still remain to be clearly described. Though there were many publications describing CSFL after surgeries on the whole spine [5678], the reports either had a small sample for thoracic decompression or did not list the incidence for each spinal segment. Also reports focusing on thoracic decompression only included relatively small sample sizes, which led to apparent inconsistencies for the CSFL incidences among the reports. For example, Yamazaki et al. [9] reported that 1 out of 24 patients with thoracic myelopathy caused by ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament (OPLL) developed CSFL, while Min et al. [10] noted 10 out of 20 patients with thoracic OPLL had this complication. There have also been a few studies having larger sample sizes, but these merely recruited patients with a certain pathology, such as OPLL, or undergoing a single surgical approach. For example, Matsumoto et al. [11] undertook a multi-institutional study involving 154 patients but only recruited those with thoracic OPLL, and Sun et al. [12] reviewed 266 patients with thoracic ossification of ligamentum flavum (OLF) for whom en bloc laminectomy was the exclusive surgical approach. Therefore, there has been a need for a comprehensive investigation of CSFL following surgeries on the thoracic spine for a relatively large series with different surgical approaches. This study was performed to meet the above requirements by reviewing 362 cases of thoracic decompression, and it aimed to review the incidence of CSFL after thoracic surgeries and its predisposing clinical parameters.
Materials and Methods
1. Patient population
The patients included in the study were diagnosed with a degenerative thoracic spinal disease and underwent decompression by experienced surgeons in our hospital from February 2005 to June 2013. Patients were excluded if they: (1) did not have complete medical records including those with previous spinal surgeries with inaccessible data from other hospitals; (2) had a history of trauma or non-surgical invasive manipulations on the thoracic spine, such as percutaneous vertebral biopsy; (3) had a history of other diseases which compromised the dural sac, such as spinal tumors; and (4) had received a combination of cervical or lumbar decompression at the same time. This study was approved by our Institutional Review Board (IRB) and was supported by two governmental grants (see the "Acknowledgments").
After the exclusions, a total of 362 consecutive cases of thoracic decompression in 345 patients were included in the study. There were 17 patients who underwent two thoracic decompressions and included 5 patients whose second decompression involved formerly operated segments.
2. Surgical procedures
In general, all the recruited operations could be categorized into three surgical approaches: posterior decompression (PD) via en bloc laminectomy with or without fusion, circumferential decompression (CD) via a transpedicular approach [13] and anterior decompression (AD) via an extrapleural (extrapleuroperitoneal) or transthoracic approach. Imaging was the main factor used in selection of a suitable surgical approach for each patient (Table 1). Particularly, PD was the initial surgical approach for all 5 cases of revision surgeries. After an average interval of 55.6 months (ranging from 3 months to 11 years), the revision surgeries were undertaken with transpedicular CD manipulations in 4 cases, with or without the extension of decompression segments, and extrapleuroperitoneal AD manipulation in 1 case on the previously operated spinal segments. In total, there were 244 cases for PD, 79 for CD and 39 for AD procedures.
Surgical approaches for different clinical scenariosa)
3. Definition of CSFL
The diagnosis of CSFL was made according to the following three criteria: (1) dural tears or appearance of clear fluid during the operation; (2) persistent drain of clear fluid from subfascial tubes; and (3) subcutaneous collection of clear fluid confirmed by puncture or aspiration.
4. Information recorded
The information collected included patient demographic data, coexisting diseases, preoperative duration of neurological symptoms and preoperative diagnoses. Imaging work-ups were reviewed and the sources of compression were recorded. Operation notes and anesthetic charts were retrieved and scrutinized to note the surgical approaches, operative duration, blood loss and operative segments. Drainage fluid from the subfascial tubes and emergence of subcutaneous fluid collection during postoperative hospital stay were also examined to determine whether CSFL occurred.
5. Data processing and statistical analysis strategies
All statistical analyses in this study were conducted in terms of operations rather than patients. IBM statistics SPSS ver. 20 (IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA) was used for statistical analysis. Descriptive statistics were presented in form of mean±standard deviation and the confidence interval was set at 95% (95% CI). The incidences of CSFL were separately decided for the entire cohort and each surgical approach. Relationships between different clinical parameters were decided by different methods, including unpaired student t test (two-tailed), Pearson's χ2 test (two-tailed) and Spearman's correlation test (two-tailed). For CSFL-associated clinical parameters, if they were recorded with continuous values, the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was drawn for each parameter and the optimal cut-off value was decided. Subsequently, the odds ratio (OR) values for all CSFL-associated parameters were calculated using multivariate logistic regression analysis. Besides, OR value of each vertebra for CSFL was also calculated. Statistical significance was set at 0.05.
Results
1. Descriptive results for the entire cohort
The cohort included 208 males and 154 females, with the mean age of 51.6±9.5 years. Imaging work-ups demonstrated OPLL in 120 cases and other pathologies in 142 cases, such as OLF and herniated discs. There were 96 cases having a comorbidity of hypertension and 47 cases having diabetes mellitus. Mean values for preoperative symptom duration were 27.0±39.6 months, the Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) scores 5.4±2.5, lengths of operative segments 3.8±1.8, operative duration 191.5±72.9 minutes and blood loss 1138.0±922.3 mL.
2. Incidence of CSFL for the entire cohort
One hundred seventeen out of 362 recruited thoracic decompressions were complicated with CSFL, yielding an incidence of 32.3% for the entire cohort (Table 2). In particular, the diagnosis of CSFL was made during postoperative hospitalization in 13 cases, for which no dural tears were intraoperatively recognized. Also, all 5 cases of patients with previously operated segments, who received an extra decompression, developed CSFL.
Incidences of cerebrospinal fluid leakage for the entire cohort and each surgical approach
3. Incidences of CSFL for different surgical approaches
There were 33 cases developing CSFL in the CD group, yielding an incidence of 41.8% for this group, which was higher than 31.1% for the PD group and 20.5% for the AD group (Table 3). Besides, the cases of missed diagnosis during the operation in three groups were 6, 7, and 0, respectively, yielding a rate of 18.2%, 9.2% and 0 for each group.
Comparison between the groups with and without cerebrospinal fluid leakage
4. Predisposing clinical factors for CSFL
Comparison analysis between the CSFL and non-CSFL subgroups demonstrated significant differences in age, preoperative JOA score, operative duration, blood loss and lengths of operative segments (p<0.05) (Table 3). There was, however, no difference in the duration of preoperative symptoms (p=0.230) (Table 3) for the two groups. According to the ROC curve for each parameter and CSFL, the optimal cut-off values of these parameters were determined (Table 4).
Analysis of clinical predisposing factors for CSF leakage
This analysis found that for patients older than 52 (OR, 1.688; 95% CI, 1.029–2.770; p=0.038), having OPLL (OR, 2.496; 95% CI, 1.368–4.553; p=0.003) or having operative segments longer than 3 vertebrae (OR, 1.725; 95% CI, 1.008–2.952; p=0.047), there were a significant risk of CSFL (Table 4). Besides, vertebrae T5 to T7 had a higher OR than other vertebrae (Fig. 1).
Diagram displaying odds ratio value of each thoracic vertebra for cerebrospinal fluid leakage. It showed that T5 (odds ratio [OR], 2.01), T6 (OR 3.01) and T7 (OR 3.77) had higher OR values than other thoracic vertebrae.
Discussion
This study found that the incidence of CSFL after thoracic decompression was 32.3%, but varied significantly across different surgical approaches (Table 2). This surgery approach-associated study of the incidence of CSFL had not been clearly reported in former publications [1114151617]. Yamazaki et al. [17] reported that the respective CSFL incidences for AD, CD and PD in a study of 51 patients with thoracic OPLL and reminded that operations including anterior manipulations had a higher risk for CSFL. Their study, however, only involved a limited sample size and did not provide detailed operative data. This present study found that CD had a significantly higher likelihood of CSFL, accounting for 41.8% of the CD subgroup (Table 2). This proportion was quite high, compared with previous publications on the same procedure [171819]. This may be due to both pathological and technical reasons. Pathologically, nearly all of CD procedures in this study were performed in patients with thoracic OPLL, which was identified as an essential risk factor for CSFL (Table 4) as there is a higher occurrence of dural adhesion in patients with OPLL than other pathologies [101620]. Technically, there is a partial or entire loss of visual supervision during anterior manipulations due to the blockage of the spinal cord, which may increase the risk of dural tears during the procedure. This shortcoming also contributed to the higher proportion of CSFL cases being intraoperatively unrecognized in CD subgroup. Generally, the emergence of clear fluid in the operative field was remarkable in alerting to dural tears in cases of lost visual supervision, but not for tiny tears, through which the egress of cerebrospinal fluid was slow and minimal. As the procedure is also accompanied by constant and plentiful bleeding, the signs of CSFL may go unnoticed during surgery. Floating and extirpation of OPLL are both accepted during CD procedure and the latter has been much more common in our hospital, aiming to avoid the potential compromise from residual ossification on the dural sac, which was demonstrated in a multi-institutional research by Matsumoto et al. [11]. However, the dissection of OPLL from the adhesive dural sac also increases the risk of CSFL. Correspondingly, in this present study 66 of 79 CD procedures were accomplished with the extirpation of OPLL, of which CSFL occurred in 35 cases, accounting for 53.0%, which was higher than 30.8% in the floating subgroup.
Previous studies, though most of which were not conducted in patients with thoracic decompression, proved that older age, massive blood loss and longer operative segments were associated with a higher risk of CSFL [14561112]. These associations were also confirmed in the present study, as well as in females, patients with lower preoperative JOA scores, having hypertension and diabetes mellitus (Table 4). This study also identified the optimal cut-off values for these clinical factors by employing ROC curves. The multivariate logistic regression analysis of all the CSFL-associated parameters, cases with age older than 52 years, having OPLL or with operative segments longer than 3 vertebrae had a significantly higher risk of CSFL (Table 4). As such, these three parameters could be recognized as the essential risk factors for CSFL. We also found that the operations involving mid-thoracic spine were more likely to develop CSFL (Fig. 1). This may be due to the compact space within the spinal canal in the mid-thoracic region. A compact spinal canal provides a limited operative space, resulting in a higher likelihood of inadvertent violation to the dural sac during surgery.
Currently, there are no convincing explanations for the associations between some of the clinical parameters and CSFL, such as being female or having hypertension and diabetes mellitus (Table 4). However, the identification of the three essential risk factors for CSFL might assist in the understanding of these unusual risk factors in a future study. As other studies have demonstrated gender disparity in prevalence of OPLL [212223], we noted that female patients in our cohort were also more likely to have OPLL. We speculated that this might be the underlying reason for the higher association between females and higher incidence of CSFL (Table 4). Also as hypertension and diabetes mellitus are age-related conditions and older age was a significant risk factor for CSFL (Table 4), this association may explain the increased risk for CSFL in this population of patients. A recent large-scale survey confirmed that diabetes mellitus was a predisposing factor for OPLL [23], and this was compatible with our finding. Furthermore, patients with lower preoperative JOA scores tended to have longer operative segments (Fig. 2), and this might result in the increased incidence of CSFL for the subgroup with preoperative JOA scores lower than 7.
Diagram displaying the relationship between preoperative JOA scores and operative segments in this cohort. The trend line indicates that operative segments negatively correlated with preoperative JOA scores (r =–0.272, p <0.05, two-tailed Spearman's correlation test). JOA, Japanese Orthopaedic Association.
In this study, only 5 cases of additional thoracic decompressions involved manipulations on formerly operated segments, and all of them developed CSFL. Thus, revision surgery was a significant risk factor for CSFL, which has been repeated proven [1368]. As statistical analysis with such few subjects is not appropriate, we did not specifically discuss it in this present study. There were also some limitations to this study: Firstly, this study was performed in a single institution, though it harbored a large sample size; as such, a multi-institutional study may be required to validate our findings. Secondly, this study was a retrospective study and its findings need to be examined this characteristic in mind. Finally, though we followed previous studies to establish the determining criteria for CSFL [612], these criteria were indirect rather than being direct evidence of CSFL. This limitation might affect the statistical results in this study.
Conclusions
Through recruiting a total of 362 cases, this study found that 32.3% of the thoracic decompressions performed were complicated with CSFL. Though many clinical factors were associated with CSFL, presence of OPLL, older age and longer operative segments were the most significant predisposing factors. In the light of the finding that the CD procedures had the highest incidence of CSFL, spinal surgeons should be mindful of this added risk performing CD procedure. This also applies to mid-thoracic decompression operations, as they also carried an additional risk for CSFL.
Acknowledgments
We hereby thank and acknowledge the support of the Capital Foundation of Characteristic Clinical Practice and Research (Grant No. Z141107002514011) and the Foundation of Science and Research Projects for Capital Health Development (Grant No. 2014-2-4094) towards this study.
Notes
Conflict of Interest: No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.